Artificial intelligence has quickly become part of our everyday lives. People use AI to research purchases, plan trips, learn about unfamiliar subjects and answer questions. It should come as no surprise that people are also beginning to use AI to help them understand their finances.
I think AI can be a very useful tool when it comes to financial planning, but how you use it matters.
I do not believe the best use of AI is to ask it to make important financial decisions for you. Instead, I believe it can be particularly valuable in helping you ask better questions and making you better prepared when you meet with your financial advisor.
One of the challenges with financial planning is that you do not always know what you do not know. You may have a financial decision in front of you, but you may not know all of the questions that should be considered before making that decision.
Retirement is a good example. Someone may initially think the main question is whether they have enough money to retire. But there are other important questions. When should I begin taking Social Security? What will my taxes look like in retirement? Which accounts should I take money from first? How will my life change when I retire? Will my values change?
This is an area where AI can be helpful.
Instead of asking AI, “Can I retire?” consider asking, “What questions should I discuss with my financial advisor before deciding whether I am ready to retire?”
That may seem like a small difference, but I think it is an important one. You are not asking AI to make the decision for you. You are asking it to help you think of questions and issues that you may not have considered.
You can use the same approach before meeting with your financial advisor. Tell the AI tool what you would like to discuss and ask it to help you prepare. AI can also help explain financial terminology you may not understand. That can allow you to spend more of your time with your advisor discussing how those concepts actually apply to you.
The goal is not to replace the conversation with your advisor. The goal is to have a better conversation.
AI can process an enormous amount of information. It can perform calculations, explain financial concepts and run through different scenarios. Those capabilities are impressive and will likely continue to improve.
But having more information is not the same as understanding what that information means for a particular person.
A financial projection may show that someone has enough money to support a certain level of spending for 25 or 30 years. That is useful information. But what is important to that person and their family? How comfortable are they with market fluctuations? What happens if their priorities or circumstances change? What do they ultimately want their money to accomplish?
Numbers can tell us a great deal, but they do not always tell us what those numbers mean to the person sitting across the table.
A good financial advisor should not simply look at what the numbers say. The advisor should also be asking why the numbers look the way they do, what could change them and what the results mean for this particular client and family. If you have been with your advisor for a while they should know how you react to market fluctuations, if you actually follow through on goals, what your values are and if you are actually being honest with your spending, risk tolerance, and your wants and needs.
As useful as AI can be, there are two important limitations to keep in mind. It can get things wrong, and it can give you an answer without having enough information to truly understand your situation.
I recently had a client send me information he had received from an AI tool concerning his required minimum distributions. The AI tool gave him the wrong age for when his required minimum distributions would begin. The answer sounded legitimate, but it was incorrect. Had he simply accepted it, he could have been making financial decisions based on bad information. This was a simple question a financial advisor would’ve been able to answer accurately.
Another client also received information from AI regarding Roth conversions. This time the problem was not necessarily a simple right or wrong answer. The AI did not have enough information about her overall financial situation to properly evaluate the decision.
A Roth conversion is not simply about how much tax you might pay today. You also need to consider what taxes may look like in the future, future required distributions and how the decision could eventually affect a spouse or other family members. The AI tool did not have the entire picture, so it could not fully understand all of the potential consequences or benefits. It’s no fault to the client, but she did not know all of the information to give the Ai tool, did not know what other scenarios to consider, or have walked through these questions with many other people like herself like a financial advisor has.
This illustrates an important point. AI generally only knows what you tell it, and you may not even know which pieces of information are important enough to provide.
AI may still give you a confident answer even when it is working with incomplete or incorrect information. That is why I believe it is better used to generate questions than to make the final decision.
Financial planning is about numbers, but it has never been only about numbers. It is about helping people use their financial resources to accomplish what matters to them. Two families with similar incomes, assets and ages can have very different goals and may need very different financial plans.
This is where experience and judgment matter. Over the years, financial advisors have the opportunity to work with people through different markets, retirements, job changes, deaths in the family, inheritances and other major life events. Those experiences teach you that the answer that looks best on a spreadsheet is not always the best answer for the person sitting in front of you.
Trust and accountability are also important parts of that relationship. When we make a recommendation, we need to be able to explain why we believe it makes sense, how it fits with the rest of a client’s financial life and what could cause us to change that recommendation in the future. Sometimes our role is to provide reassurance. Other times it is to ask a client to reconsider a decision or look at it from a different perspective.
AI can provide information and analyze a tremendous amount of data, and I expect it will become an increasingly useful tool for both advisors and clients. But good financial planning requires more than information. It requires understanding the person, their family, their priorities and what they ultimately want their money to accomplish. Sometimes we need people in our lives to push back against our assumptions, thoughts, and behavior. We don’t need people or technology who are always agreeable and tell us what we want to hear. A good financial advisor is willing to have tough conversations in order to help you make sound financial decisions.
Use AI to become better informed, to ask better questions and to prepare for conversations with your advisor. Your financial advisor can use their experience and judgment when the answer isn’t obvious, keep you accountable to make sure it gets done, be trustworthy when the stakes are highest, and be someone who understands your complete financial picture to help put answers to your questions into context.
AI can help you find information and ask better questions. The value of an advisor is helping you understand what those answers mean for you.